Managing Invasive Plant Species in Ecological Restoration
Drawn from a Polster Environmental report on the role of invasive species management in terrestrial ecosystem restoration
The Problem
Invasive species pose a significant problem in British Columbia. They degrade native ecosystems, reducing the value of these ecosystems to their human as well as non-human inhabitants. Invasive species management programs are conducted by a variety of government and non-government agencies, organizations and companies. Methods of determining the priority for treatment differ among the managing groups, although few rank ecosystem health as a major determining factor in deciding treatment programs and priorities. Ranking systems use criteria such as aggressiveness, reproductive strategies, extent of populations and ability to control as criteria for assessing management priorities.
An Ecological Approach to Invasive Species
The strategy outlined here has been developed to be appropriate to ecosystem restoration work where ecosystems have been damaged by past management practices. Although the suggested practices have been developed from traditional weed science techniques, they have been modified to enhance restoration rather than with some economic objective in mind.
For an invasive plant species to be successfully removed from a community, the disturbance factor that allowed the alien to invade in the first place must be removed and the habitat restored to as near its original condition as possible (Thomas 1986). This habitat restoration can involve restoring the native dominants, re-establishing natural disturbance regimes, filling vacant niches with natives, restoring natural densities, restoring age and class structures, and correcting any disturbed physical conditions (Thomas 1986). If these steps are not taken, the removal of an exotic species may be followed by re-invasion of the same species or establishment of another exotic (Thomas 1986). This is the key to successful invasive species management within the context of ecological restoration. In other words, recognize the processes that have lead to establishment of invasive species, correct the deficiencies and maintain a healthy ecosystem.
Selecting Restoration Projects
Key selection criteria for effective restoration projects involving invasive species management are:
- Selection of projects that enhance ecosystem integrity through removal of invasive species and replacement by appropriate native species; and
- Selection of projects that address the potential for invasive species establishment and provide appropriate strategies for dealing with invasive species when they occur.
Restoration projects that enhance the integrity of the natural ecosystem should be encouraged while those that degrade ecosystem integrity should be avoided. Removal of invasive species and replacement, through planting or natural establishment with native species that are found in the ecosystem being treated, can be an effective strategy for ecosystem restoration. Projects that include both the removal of invasive species and the replacement by native ecosystem components should be selected over those that just consider removal of invasive species with no regard to subsequent vegetation health.
Ecosystem restoration projects that address the potential for invasive species establishment should be selected over projects where strategies for dealing with invasive species are not addressed. Many ecosystem restoration programs focus on replanting damaged and degraded sites without regard to the potential for invasive species establishment. Similarly, projects involved in the re-establishment of natural fire disturbance regimes may result in encouragement of fire resistant invasive species by reducing competition with natives that are less resistant.
Prevention and Disturbance
Prevention of invasive plant species establishment is often cited as the most economical approach to invasive species management. Yet the majority of past funding has been carried out on a reactive, rather than proactive, basis. Prevention requires education, establishing practices that promote healthy ecosystems, cooperation and consistency of management. Prevention of invasion can be achieved by minimizing disturbances, by quickly revegetating disturbed areas, and by maintaining healthy ecosystems. These provide the best management approaches.
Existing conditions and resources must meet the plant autecological requirements for an invasive species to establish. For the majority of invasive species, some form of disturbance or altered vegetation cover, reduced or impoverished, is necessary for establishment. Most invasive species such as hound's-tongue, knapweeds, thistles, and many others in the Asteraceae Family are pioneer species and any soil disturbance can provide a suitable site for establishment. Attempts to prevent establishment, to contain or to eradicate invasive plant species will likely be unsuccessful if the initial disturbance that allowed the species to invade the area is still occurring.
Conversely, healthy, undisturbed grasslands can better withstand weed infestations without being dominated by them, and some native grassland communities are more resistant than others. For example, grassland communities dominated by rough fescue (Festuca campestris) seem more resistant to knapweeds than nearby blue-bunch wheatgrass (Elymus spicatus) communities (Sturko and Wikeem 1990). Understanding this provides a foundation for management techniques that exploit the strengths of the native ecosystems. It bears repeating that if efforts are not undertaken to help re-colonization of disturbed areas by native species, the disturbances may result in increasingly problematic invasive species establishing.
Summary of Management Techniques
Effective management of invasive species must be based on the species and the particulars of the site where they occur. The use of specific techniques such as cutting, burning, or herbicides will depend on the circumstances of the invasive species and the site. Recognizing this constraint, the following general management techniques are recommended:
- Avoid the use of invasive species in horticulture and landscaping, and work to prevent the use of these species by others;
- Prevent movement of invasive species from known infested areas by identifying infestations, containing them, and treating them (mowing, spraying, cutting, hand pulling) to prevent spread;
- Prevent establishment of invasive species by maintaining healthy ecosystems;
- Avoid the use of contaminated seed during revegetation work; use high quality seed that has fewer weed seeds;
- Minimize the transportation of weed-containing materials such as hay bales (often used for sediment control) from an area of infestation to new, weed-free areas;
- Minimize and/or contain disturbances and disturbance-creating activities (e.g. avoid unrestricted ATV travel across rangelands);
- Revegetate disturbed sites promptly with appropriate native species where possible, and avoid invasive species such as crested wheatgrass, orchardgrass and sweetclover;
- Avoid fragmentation of native habitats by roads, trails and other corridors of invasive species movement;
- Patrol existing corridors to identify and control invasive species that manage to move in;
- Provide native species competitors for invasive species (e.g. red alder can out-compete blackberry);
- Prevent dissemination of invasive species through timely mowing or cutting prior to flowering and seed set;
- Contain invasive species infestations by working from the perimeters of the infestation towards the centre;
- Identify and manage pathways of infestation, with particular attention to dissemination centres, corridors and intersections; and
- Avoid movement of weed-seed-containing materials, including gravel from gravel pits and rock from quarries.
Seeding as Prevention
Seeding newly disturbed areas with desirable species is an effective means of providing quick cover before weeds can get established. Despite the fact that seeding is prescribed by the Forest Practices Code when soil disturbances occur, very little seeding is done in conjunction with other management practices such as herbicide applications. Approval under the Canada Seed Act (e.g. Canada No. 1 seed) does not mean the seed source is weed free; native seed may still contain unacceptable invasive plant species. The weed seed content, as determined by seed analysis, is more important than the grade of the seed. The most practical approach is to exclude invasive forage species from natural areas, conservation lands, and general erosion-control work. Earlier use of exotic legumes and grasses contributed to their spread (Haber 1996).
Hand Pulling and Cutting
Hand pulling is mostly effective for small patches of annuals and biennials. Pulling must be done in such a way as to minimize further soil disturbance, and disturbed areas should be reseeded as soon as possible. Hand cutting, like hand pulling, is also mostly effective for small patches and for annuals and biennials. Repeated hand cutting can also be done in an attempt to deplete carbohydrate reserves. Generally for perennials, but also for some biennials and annuals, cutting should be done below or at the root collar to help prevent regeneration.
Mowing
Mowing, like any management technique, shifts species composition by selecting against those that do not resist or tolerate mowing and favouring others along a "mowing" preferential gradient. For example, repeated mowing in the spring is detrimental to cool season grasses and favours warm season grasses; repeated mowing during the warm season will favour cool season grasses. A management strategy aiming at reducing cool season grasses, such as quack grass, could target mowing programs during the cool months, which can shift species composition by as much as 50 percent (Diboll 1984). Mowing can be most effective when target species are dicotyledonous species in competition with grasses, as the native grasses regrow most effectively from their intercalary meristem.
Burning
Burning has some degree of success, although most invasive species tend to be opportunistic, and burning can indirectly favour exotic species establishment by providing open spaces. Experience in British Columbia suggests that burning stimulates most weed growth, primarily through creation of a seedbed and reduced competitive vegetation vigour. However, burning coupled with a rapid establishment of vigorous grasses and legumes, such as by seeding, can be an effective way of restoring range health. Burning combined with fertilization generally increased production of native species and suppressed exotics such as smooth brome (Masters 1992).
Herbicide Application
Applications of herbicides, made in accordance with industry standards and good practices for vegetation management, are powerful tools, particularly for perennials with extensive root systems that would be very difficult to control otherwise. Systemic herbicides usually work best when plants are actively translocating, which can carry the herbicide to all plant parts. For this reason, the most susceptible stage of biennials for systemic herbicide application is the early rosette stage, when the rosettes are storing carbohydrates in their root system.
Herbicide applications, however, have the potential to adversely affect ecosystems by leaving open "gaps" in the vegetation where exotic species can readily invade (Gillette 1983; Polster and Landry 1993). It is thus imperative that herbicide application be combined with a program of replacement of targeted vegetation. Otherwise, although the short-term results may appear successful in reducing the number of existing invasive species, re-establishment of the invasive species will occur. Current management practices that focus mainly on herbicide applications, despite their integration into well-intentioned pest management plans, are not effective solutions even if they may temporarily appear to be.
About This Resource
This resource draws on the management sections of a Polster Environmental report on invasive species in terrestrial ecosystem restoration. It focuses on treating the disturbance and restoring a healthy native ecosystem rather than addressing symptoms alone.
Put these methods to work on your site
Polster Environmental Services designs and installs soil bioengineering and natural-process restoration across British Columbia, including mine reclamation, riparian restoration, and slope stabilization.
Mount Tzouhalem: clearing broom, recovering flower meadows
David Polster's field record follows Mount Tzouhalem Ecological Reserve from broom-dominated conditions in 1994 to returning native flowers in 1999.
Scotch broom had overgrown parts of the Mount Tzouhalem Ecological Reserve.
Source: David Polster, Segment Mt Tzuhalem ER strategy. This is an attributed ecological-restoration field record, not a PES client-project claim or a fixed-camera survey comparison.